Lily, I had discussions lately about the whole experience of shaming and what it means to others. We talk so much about shaming kids, yet do we talk much about shaming as adults? Or is it just accepted?
What an interesting topic HJ.
Well, I guess, it really depends on what connotation you have on the word “shaming”. For me “shaming” is disgraceful.
… the act or activity of subjecting someone to shame, disgrace, humiliation, or disrepute especially by public exposure or criticism.
from merriam webster dictionary
I’ve experienced “being shamed” as a child and young adult but had discovered the impact of “being shamed” as an adult had so much more of an impact on me. Maybe it was just the “last straw that broke the camel’s back” as “they” say.
Isn’t it interesting to find out why we do what we do today?
I guess, a lot of things were small things but it adds up.
Shame is a soul eating emotion.
Carl G. Jung
As a “fat” kid, I was a target for shaming. Struggling in class, I was a target for the teachers. Back when I was at school in the 60’s, teachers seemed to enjoy bringing attention to the kids who misbehaved, didn’t perform well or got low grades. I called it “shame into change”. Doesn’t work.
Looking back now, I was a target for shaming because of my cultural difference. Regardless of how much I tried, I was different. I didn’t know what was “normal” to other kids. In my days, immigrants were reasonably rare and I think my friends were just curios of the differences yet for me it was painful experience.
A good example is lunch box. I feel “shaming” not to have something similar to my friends. I didn’t want to have rice balls when all my friends had sandwich. I didn’t want to have fried rice when my friends had rice balls. Yes, I know, this is quite cultural isn’t it?
The truth is, unless you let go, unless you forgive yourself, unelss you forgive the situation, unless yyou realise that the situation is over, you cannot move forward.
Dr. Steve Maraboli
I was really good at netball as a kid. You learn to take the “shaming” from the other team and their supporters cause “that just part of the game”.
Sledging it’s now called the insulting of an opposing player in order to upset his or her concentration.
Thankfully over the years this type of behaviour was stopped from those off the court, yet it was done on court both physically and verbally. I learnt to play not just the game of netball but all the on court antics.
High school was also “shaming” as I was again the “fat kid”. All of this didn’t stop till I left high school and attended Business College. Very strict rules there and this was never allowed.
For me, ‘shame’ has connotation of ‘disgraceful’. For me, it is disgraceful to my family.
Let me share a story about how my family thought I was “disgraceful to the family” because I was “fat”.
I remember my mother once said “Aren’t you ashamed? that you can’t control your weight. Aren’t you worried that you don’t have partner? I am worried that because you are so fat, you don’t have chance to find a partner.” This perspective include cultural believe of girls need to find a partner and marry, become a mother. That’s the ideal life of born as a woman. And the whole notion of ideal body image for girls. Girls need to look slim and pretty to be loved by another person.
If you put shame in a petri dish, it need three ingridients to grow expotentially: secrecy, silence, and judgement. If you put the same amount of shame in the petri dish and douse it with empathy, it can’t survive.
Brené Brown
My first few jobs were great and I got to use my skills and worked in an environment where I felt supported and appreciated.
It was out in the social world that the shaming was rife. I really never understood what you gain from shaming and belittling another for any reason. The obvious physical appearance of another causes “horrible” comments with little to no regard to how that makes the person feel.
When I was a kid, I was trained as a swimmer. Back then, people said “that’s amazing. You ate a lot” with encouraging tone. When I stopped swimming people still said “that’s amazing. You ate a lot.” Yet, this time with negative tone, meaning “I ate too much.”
Eventually, I had to lose weight due to health reasons. One day, my mum saw me after I lost about 10kg, she said “I finally had my daughter back.” That really shocked me how my mother viewed me all those years. Yes, I can’t deny all those comments seemed harmless from my family members but it was toxic. It toxicated my self-confidence and self-esteem. All those years, I believed I wasn’t good enough for others to love, or even liked. I need to be super kind to others to compensate for the flaws for others to be friend with me.
When a toxic person can no longer control you, they will try to control how others see you.
Jill Blakeway
The misinformation will feel unfair, but stay above it, trusting that other people will eventually see the truth, just like you did.
Now I realise how sad it is for the person who has to knock another down to make themselves feel good. At the time it is devastating. So much so, my first real experience of the damage “shaming” does was when I was 17 and a young man who felt he was a young woman and exploring what that meant was treated horrendously in social situations. He was my friend and I did my best to help and protect him. He truly was struggling and in the end, ended his life. That had such a huge impact on me and how I lived my life and treated others.
“Shaming” didn’t stop during my life. So many delighted in making life as difficult for others as possible. I still don’t understand what’s going on for them to feel they can do that.
You have reminded me one of my experience as a child. When I was year 5, I have experienced isolation from the whole class. It was a sudden change, I didn’t know what to do. It went on for a year. As it started suddenly, it stopped suddenly too. I was just so shocked in how people can change their mind. What I have learned from this experience? I learned to stand tall if I can’t find the reason it was my fault. It was a struggle for me to attend school everyday without a fail. I had a ritual to myself those days which stated “The true defeat is when I give in to those people who are ignoring me in the class.”
How did I kept going?
I had people behind me who had my back. My parents knew the situation, so did my teacher. I heard many people critised his inability to handle the situation yet I appreciate his trust in me. When he knew the situation, he actually asked me what I want to do with the situation. I told him I think I am okay so don’t do anything. Don’t even highlight it in the class. That’s what he did for me. I promised him that when I can’t handle anymore, I will let him know immediately. To this date, I still appreciate his trust and courage to let me handle the situation as how I wanted. Because of them had my back, I was able attend the school everyday.
What was the outcome of this experience?
I have learned how to enjoy my time alone. I learned the fun of human observation and story writing. More to this experience is years later, a lead person who isolated me from the school visited me in Australia. Well, she shared that she had experienced similar situation in her highschool days. Regardless of what happened during my primary school days, we were able to share fun time together.
People who repeatedly attack your confidence and self-esteem are quite aware of your potential, even if you are not.
Wayne Gerard Trotman
Anyway, where was I going with this? Well, the idea came from a memory I shared this week of an experience of being “shamed” as an adult.
I love to dance. Always have done from a young age. Always “bopping” to music. I love learning ballroom classes, latin american classes, jazzacise classes and especially going to night clubs and dancing all night.
This particular instance, I can still see it and feel it, I was at the Tewantin RSL (Sunshine Coast Qld) in April 2014 with a group of new friends. We were there to see and band and dance to their music. I was much older than the rest (59 yrs young). The girls all decided to get up and dance. Three of the five young women (in their 30’s) started standing aside and told me I looked so silly and couldn’t dance and what was I doing and moved away from me. The friend who invited me didn’t say anything and joined them.
I was humiliated. Up until then I was enjoying myself. I didn’t see myself as any better or worse than anyone else on the floor. To be left alone by the group really embarrassed me.
I have not got back on a dance floor since. Oh, I did take up an offer to join a dance class for over 60’s a few years ago and was told by one of the men that I couldn’t dance.
The only time I dance now is in my home, or with children.
What an experience?
You have reminded me about my mother.
After sizing down, my mum now watches every kilo of weight I put on. She is making sure that I am keeping my best weight by asking me “Have you put on weight?” This is every single time she sees me. One day, I responded “Thank you mum for keep reminding me about my weight. I really don’t need it because I am totally aware of what’s happening with my weight. I feel sad and shamed everytime you ask my weight and I really don’t need those comments. Can you keep it to yourself? I don’t want to hear it anymore.”
Since then, she will still occassionally comment yet she is more gentle with her comment.
It is always been a mystery to me how people can respect themselves when they humiliate other humans.
Mahatma Gandhi
I’m told no one can hurt you unless you let them. Sounds great in theory, yet if you hammer a nail into a piece of wood and pull it out, there is still the hole left from the nail.
Every little or big piece of “shaming” has a impact on a child’s/person’s self esteem, self worth and it stacks up chipping away each time till the child/person can take no more. Let’s all realise this and start encouraging, each other, building up rather than tearing down. There is no right way to do anything. Let’s all just have fun and allow each other to enjoy life. It’s a gift for us all to enjoy.
Life is best lived by being bold and daring. People tend to grow fearful when they taste failure, face a daunting challenge or fall ill. Yet that is precisely the time to become even bolder. Those who are victors at heart are the greatest of all champions.
Daisaku Ikeda




























